Failed payments in SaaS can cost businesses up to 1.5% of annual revenue and contribute to 48% of subscription churn. Here's why payments fail and how to fix them:
- Top Causes: Insufficient funds (53%), expired cards (24%), incorrect payment details (30%), and fraud prevention systems.
- Impact: Involuntary churn (20–40% of total churn), lost revenue, and higher operating costs (up to $70 per failed payment).
- Solutions: Automated retries, dunning systems, proactive communication, and offering backup payment methods.
Key Takeaway: Addressing failed payments quickly can recover 45–70% of revenue and improve customer retention. Simple strategies like retry logic, clear messaging, and multiple payment options can make a big difference.
Collecting failed payments - Payment Failure System - What You Need To Know
Why Payments Fail in SaaS Businesses
To tackle payment failures effectively, SaaS businesses need to understand why they happen in the first place. By identifying common causes, patterns emerge that can inform strategies to reduce these disruptions.
Credit Card Issues
Credit cards are at the heart of most payment failures in SaaS. The reasons vary, but the numbers tell a clear story:
- Insufficient funds: This accounts for 53% of recurring payment failures.
- Expired cards: These are responsible for 24% of failures.
- Invalid payment details: Errors like incorrect card numbers, billing addresses, ZIP codes, or outdated CVV codes contribute to 30% of failures.
Another challenge comes from banks blocking card-not-present (CNP) transactions. Since SaaS payments often fall into this category, they can be flagged due to fraud concerns. On top of this, risk management systems designed to protect against fraud can inadvertently cause payment declines.
Fraud Prevention Systems
Fraud detection tools are essential for safeguarding against threats, but they’re not perfect. Sometimes, these systems block legitimate transactions, leading to what’s called a false decline. And the impact is significant: 56% of U.S. consumers and 40% of global consumers have experienced a false payment decline in the past 90 days.
In subscription-based models, fraud filters may flag transactions as suspicious due to unusual timing, location, or inconsistent patterns. While these systems are meant to protect, technical misconfigurations can further complicate matters, disrupting payments unnecessarily.
Technical Setup Problems
Technical issues are another common culprit. Problems like API misconfigurations, network errors, or incorrect billing cycle setups can all interfere with recurring payments. Additionally, compliance requirements, such as multi-factor authentication (SCA) under PSD2 in the EU, add another layer of complexity. If your system isn’t equipped to handle these requirements, even legitimate transactions can fail.
Soft vs. Hard Declines
A key part of understanding payment failures lies in distinguishing between soft declines and hard declines. These two categories require very different approaches to resolution.
- Soft declines happen when the payment method is valid, but the transaction fails due to temporary issues like insufficient funds, temporary card holds, or billing address changes. These make up 80–90% of all declines and are often resolved without customer involvement.
- Hard declines, on the other hand, occur when the payment method is no longer valid. This includes lost or stolen cards, fraudulent activity, invalid card numbers, expired cards, or closed accounts. These are more challenging to recover, with about 70% of falsely declined transactions falling into this category.
Here’s a quick comparison:
| Feature | Soft Decline | Hard Decline |
|---|---|---|
| Validity of Payment Method | Valid | Invalid |
| Nature of Issue | Temporary | Permanent |
| Customer Intervention Required | No (often) | Yes (usually) |
| Retryable | Yes | No |
| Common Causes | Insufficient funds, billing address changes, temporary holds, technical issues | Lost/stolen card, fraudulent activity, invalid card number, expired card, closed bank account |
For SaaS businesses, recognizing this distinction is crucial. Soft declines can often be resolved by retrying the payment after a short delay. Hard declines, however, require immediate action from the customer, such as updating payment details or providing a new payment method. Mismanaging either type - like repeatedly retrying hard declines - can lead to wasted resources or even trigger fraud alerts. On the flip side, ignoring soft declines can mean losing out on recoverable revenue.
How Failed Payments Hurt SaaS Businesses
Failed payments can ripple through every corner of a SaaS business, causing issues that go far beyond a single declined transaction. They disrupt revenue, strain customer relationships, and increase operational burdens, creating challenges that often multiply over time.
Involuntary Churn
One of the most damaging consequences of failed payments is involuntary churn - when customers unintentionally stop their subscriptions because their payment didn’t go through. These are customers who want to stay but are lost due to payment processing issues. In fact, involuntary churn can make up 20–40% of the total churn in subscription-based businesses.
What’s even more alarming? The average recovery rate for failed payments hovers around 70%, meaning nearly a third of these customers are lost permanently. For high-value enterprise clients, a single payment failure could result in tens of thousands of dollars in lost revenue. And this isn’t just about immediate income - future revenue potential takes a hit too. This kind of loss can shake a company’s financial stability and confidence, making it harder to address other challenges.
Customer Trust Problems
Failed payments don’t just hurt the bottom line - they also damage customer trust. When payment issues happen often, customers may begin to doubt the company’s reliability. They might worry about service interruptions and start looking for alternatives that seem more dependable.
This erosion of trust can have a lasting impact. It’s not just about losing current customers - potential new subscribers may hesitate to sign up if the brand’s reputation takes a hit. And once trust is broken, rebuilding it is no easy task. Research shows that even increasing customer retention by just 5% can lead to a 75% boost in profitability, underscoring how crucial it is to maintain strong, trust-based relationships.
Higher Operating Costs
The fallout from failed payments doesn’t stop at lost revenue and trust - it also drives up operating costs. Recovering a failed payment isn’t cheap. When you factor in systems, staff, and missed opportunities, the cost to recover a single failed payment can range from $40 to $70. To put that in perspective, resolving a failed payment on a $29 monthly subscription might cost more than two months’ worth of revenue.
Customer service teams often spend 15–20 minutes handling each failed payment inquiry, which, at an average wage of $30 per hour, adds up to about $7.50 per incident. Meanwhile, finance teams may spend 5–20 hours each month reconciling failed payments and addressing their impact on accounting processes.
And then there’s the need for technical solutions. Businesses frequently invest in tools like retry logic, dunning systems, and fraud detection software to manage payment issues more effectively. While these tools are necessary, they come with ongoing costs that can slow growth and make it harder to stay competitive.
In short, failed payments don’t just cause short-term headaches - they create long-term challenges that are difficult and expensive to overcome.
sbb-itb-a989baf
How to Fix Failed Payment Problems
Dealing with failed payments can be tricky, but most issues can be resolved with a mix of automated retries, personalized follow-ups, and clear communication. By adopting smart processes and thoughtful outreach, SaaS companies can recover lost revenue while keeping customers satisfied.
Automatic Retry Systems
Automated retry systems are a powerful tool to recover failed payments without manual effort. But not every failed payment should be retried the same way. The key is knowing when retries are worthwhile.
When to Retry Payments
Before retrying, analyze the response status code and error details. Temporary issues like connection timeouts, internal server errors (500), or service unavailable errors (503) are good candidates for retries. On the other hand, errors like bad requests (400), unauthorized errors (401), or not found errors (404) typically can’t be fixed by retrying.
| Error Type | Retry Recommended | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Connection Timeout | Yes | Likely a temporary network issue |
| 429: Too Many Requests | Yes (with delay) | Retry after rate limits reset |
| 500: Internal Server Error | Yes | Temporary server problem |
| 400: Bad Request | No | Incorrect request format |
| 401: Unauthorized | No | Authentication issue |
| 404: Not Found | No | Resource doesn’t exist |
For temporary errors, use exponential backoff to space out retries. For example, retry after 1 minute, then 4 minutes, then 16 minutes, and so on. Limit retries to 3-5 attempts over 72 hours to avoid overloading systems and maintain good relationships with payment processors.
Fine-tune retry schedules using historical data. Analyzing past success rates, transaction types, and customer payment trends can help you create retry intervals that recover more payments while keeping costs low.
Once retries are set up, the next step is managing customer outreach through a well-designed dunning process.
Dunning Management Best Practices
A strong dunning system combines automation with personalized communication to help customers resolve payment issues quickly and easily.
Prevent Failures Before They Happen
Proactive communication can stop many payment issues before they arise. For example, notify customers about upcoming card expirations, low account balances, or missing payment details 7-10 days before their next billing cycle. In-app notifications are especially effective since they reach users while they’re engaged with your service.
Separate Emails from Payment Retries
Don’t overload customers with too many messages. Keep dunning emails focused on guiding customers to update their payment details, while retry logic works in the background to handle technical recovery attempts.
Personalize Your Outreach
Tailor dunning workflows to meet the needs of different customer groups. For example, high-value accounts might warrant direct phone calls and personalized support, while smaller accounts can receive automated email sequences with self-service options. As Aditya Tulsian, Director at Chargebee Receivables, puts it:
"Your mantra for collections should be that every customer is unique and requires personalized communication. Like any good marketing strategy, take time to fully understand your target audience and their behavior for an effective engagement."
Optimize for Mobile
Since over 70% of payment updates happen on mobile devices, ensure your payment update pages are mobile-friendly. Allowing customers to update their payment details without logging in can also boost update rates significantly.
Real-world examples highlight the impact of effective dunning. For instance, Recover Payments by LTVplus helped Awesome Motive recover over $17,000 in just five months by refining their dunning process and running targeted campaigns. Similarly, Whiteboard reduced involuntary churn and increased monthly recurring revenue by 35% through improved workflows.
How to Communicate with Customers
Even with the best retry and dunning systems, how you communicate about payment issues can make or break your recovery efforts. Customers are often frustrated when payments fail, so your messaging should be empathetic, helpful, and solution-driven.
Provide Clear, Actionable Steps
Don’t just inform customers of a problem - tell them exactly how to fix it. Include direct links to update payment details, contact numbers for support, and simple, step-by-step instructions.
Use Multiple Channels
Relying solely on email can limit your reach. Combine email with SMS, in-app notifications, and phone calls for high-value accounts. Each channel should complement the others without overwhelming the customer.
Timing Is Critical
Send the first notification immediately after a payment fails, followed by reminders at intervals like 3 days, 7 days, and 14 days. For monthly subscriptions, advance reminders before the next billing cycle can help prevent repeated failures.
Show Customers They Matter
Make your communication personal. Reference their subscription history, usage patterns, or favorite features to demonstrate their importance to your business. This approach reinforces the value of staying subscribed.
Offer Flexible Solutions
Some customers prefer self-service options like one-click payment updates, while others might want to talk to a support representative. Provide both options and make it clear that help is available if needed.
When done right, these strategies work. Up to 70% of failed payments can be recovered with a thoughtful combination of retry logic and customer communication. Businesses that neglect customer outreach often face higher churn and lower recovery rates. A little extra effort in communication can make a huge difference.
Tools to Prevent and Handle Payment Failures
Managing payment failures effectively can turn a potential revenue loss into an opportunity to improve customer retention and satisfaction. For SaaS businesses, having the right tools in place means identifying issues early, automating recovery, and offering backup solutions when primary payment methods fall through.
Payment Analytics and Monitoring
Payment analytics tools collect data from platforms like PayPal and Stripe, giving you a complete picture of customer payment behavior and failure trends.
Track the Right Metrics
Key metrics such as failure rate, retry success, recovery time, and churn provide valuable insights. Analyzing these by customer segments, payment methods, and regions can help you pinpoint issues before they grow into bigger problems. Studies show that failed transactions account for up to 3.6% of annual revenue losses, with nearly 35% of transactions failing. For a SaaS company earning $1 million annually, that’s a potential loss of $36,000.
Real-Time Insights
Using tools with real-time monitoring capabilities allows you to react quickly to payment failures. This proactive approach not only minimizes revenue loss but also helps maintain customer trust.
Popular options for payment analytics include BlueSnap (rated 4.1/5 on G2), Databox (4.4/5 on G2), ProfitWell Metrics by Paddle (4.8/5 on G2), and Putler (4.6/5 on G2). These platforms offer features like detailed dashboards and subscription-focused metrics, helping you take immediate action when issues arise.
By combining analytics with automation, businesses can address payment failures more efficiently and recover lost revenue.
Built-in Dunning Systems
Automated dunning systems play a crucial role in reducing involuntary churn by sending timely reminders and assisting customers in updating their payment details.
Automation Saves Time and Retains Customers
High involuntary churn and rising recovery costs can be mitigated with automated systems that integrate seamlessly with your billing platform. These systems handle everything from retrieving client details to scheduling communications. For SaaS companies, failed payments and involuntary churn can lead to a loss of around 9% of monthly recurring revenue (MRR). However, well-optimized systems can recover 70-80% of failed payments.
Features to Look For
When choosing a dunning system, prioritize features like automated reminders, intelligent retry logic, and integration with your existing billing system. Effective systems start with gentle reminders and escalate communication only when necessary. They also provide insights into customer behavior, helping you refine your recovery strategies over time.
Unlike traditional debt collection, SaaS dunning emphasizes customer retention through polite, automated communication. The aim is to resolve payment issues without damaging the customer relationship.
When paired with actionable analytics, dunning systems can address payment problems almost immediately.
Multiple Payment Options
Diversifying payment methods is another essential strategy. It ensures that customers have alternatives when their primary payment method fails, helping to stabilize revenue streams.
Minimize Involuntary Churn
Offering multiple payment options can significantly reduce involuntary churn. For instance, if a customer’s credit card expires or a bank error occurs, having a backup payment method ensures their subscription continues uninterrupted.
Tackle Common Issues
Each payment method comes with its own set of challenges. By providing alternatives, you can prevent disruptions caused by technical or financial issues with a single payment method.
Catering to Global Customers
For businesses with international customers, supporting region-specific payment options is critical. Features like localized payment methods and currency support help reduce friction and build trust among global users.
How to Implement
Integrate your subscription management system with a payment gateway that supports a wide range of options. Encourage customers to set up backup payment methods in advance, so they’re prepared if their primary method fails.
Key Points for SaaS Businesses
To strengthen revenue streams and retain customers, SaaS companies must address payment failures head-on. This is especially crucial since 20-40% of churn is involuntary, meaning customers want to stay but encounter payment issues.
Use smart automation: Machine learning–powered retry systems can dramatically improve payment recovery. For instance, Deliveroo recaptured over £100 million in just one year using Stripe's Smart Retries and other recovery tools. Similarly, Retool recovered more than $600,000 in revenue last year with the same strategy. These systems analyze payment patterns and retry transactions at optimal times, increasing the chances of success.
Differentiate retry strategies for soft and hard declines. Soft declines, like temporary card issues, should be retried quickly, while hard declines, such as canceled cards, require a longer timeline - sometimes weeks. This tailored approach avoids unnecessary retries and maximizes recovery potential.
Time communications effectively. According to industry experts, reaching customers during peak business hours, rather than immediately after a failed payment, leads to better engagement.
Prioritize customer experience. By addressing payment issues early, RankingCoach increased their payment success rate by 18% in just two months. The Seattle Times boosted retention by 25% after identifying that 62% of their churn was due to payment failures and simplifying their payment process. These examples highlight the value of proactive engagement.
Encourage backup payment methods. Tools like Stripe and Braintree can automatically update card details without requiring customer action. Additionally, urging customers to add backup payment options ahead of time can help prevent disruptions in service.
Offer subscription pauses. Instead of immediately canceling subscriptions, give customers the option to pause their service. This approach maintains the relationship while allowing time to resolve payment issues.
The results speak for themselves: Recurly reports a 49% annual dunning recovery rate and saves 72% of at-risk subscribers each year. Subscriptions recovered through these strategies typically continue for an average of seven more months. An optimized retry strategy can recover 45-70% of failed payments, turning what could be seen as technical hurdles into opportunities to build stronger customer relationships.
FAQs
What’s the difference between soft and hard payment declines, and how can SaaS businesses handle them effectively?
Soft and hard declines happen for different reasons, and each requires a unique approach to resolve. Soft declines usually stem from temporary issues like insufficient funds or mismatched billing details. These can often be fixed by retrying the payment or asking customers to update their information. In contrast, hard declines are more permanent, caused by things like expired cards or closed accounts, and they require customers to provide a new payment method.
For SaaS businesses looking to boost recovery rates, automating retries for soft declines with smart retry logic can make a big difference. Promptly notifying customers about failed payments is also key. When dealing with hard declines, proactive communication is essential. Sending reminders or providing an easy way for customers to update their payment details can reduce churn and ensure their service continues without interruption.
How can SaaS businesses reduce involuntary churn caused by failed payments?
To reduce involuntary churn caused by failed payments, SaaS businesses can take several effective steps. One approach is to use smart retry logic, which involves retrying failed payments at strategic intervals - like after 1, 3, and 7 days. This method can recover payments without frustrating customers. Another helpful tool is account updater services, which automatically update payment details, such as expired credit cards, ensuring uninterrupted service.
It’s also important to provide various payment options to cater to customer preferences. Pair this with automated reminders - via email or in-app notifications - to encourage customers to resolve payment issues promptly. These measures not only keep subscriptions running smoothly but also improve the customer experience and help prevent revenue loss.
How can SaaS platforms optimize automated retries to address different payment failures?
To handle payment failures more effectively, SaaS platforms can benefit from implementing smart retry logic. This approach tailors retry attempts based on the specific error type. For instance, if a payment fails due to insufficient funds, it’s better to retry after a few days. On the other hand, for expired cards, allowing more time for customers to update their payment details can lead to better outcomes.
Another key practice is setting a limit on retry attempts. Overdoing retries can frustrate customers and harm the relationship. Regularly monitoring the performance of these retries and analyzing the data can help fine-tune retry intervals, striking the right balance between recovery rates and customer satisfaction. By using these methods, SaaS businesses can recover more payments while keeping churn to a minimum and relationships intact.
